The English Association warmly welcomes the IPPR report What Comes Next? A Fairer Approach to Primary Assessment and its call for a more equitable, inclusive and educationally meaningful approach to assessment in primary schools.
We strongly support the report’s first four recommendations. Together, they offer an important opportunity to reconsider the relationship between assessment, accountability and the curriculum, and to ensure that the richness and breadth of children’s educational experiences are not compromised by the demands of high-stakes testing.
As a subject association for English, we believe it is particularly important to recognise that English is a complex, interconnected and creative subject. It encompasses reading, writing, speaking and listening, alongside the exploration of language and literature in all their forms. Learning in English is about much more than acquiring a set of discrete, measurable skills. It involves developing an understanding of how language works, finding and expressing one’s own voice, engaging with different perspectives and experiences, exercising imagination and creativity, and learning to interpret, question and make meaning.
We strongly endorse the recommendation for independent accessibility and bias audits of Key Stage 2 assessments. All children should have a fair opportunity to demonstrate their knowledge, understanding and capabilities. Assessments must not inadvertently privilege particular cultural experiences, linguistic backgrounds or forms of knowledge. We would particularly welcome scrutiny of the cultural assumptions embedded in reading passages and writing tasks, the accessibility of assessment language, and the extent to which children with different linguistic backgrounds and educational needs can demonstrate what they know and can do. Fairness does not mean lowering expectations; it means ensuring that assessments genuinely measure what they set out to measure.
We support the removal of the standalone Spelling, Punctuation and Grammar (SPaG) test. This should not be interpreted as a diminution of the importance of spelling, punctuation or grammatical knowledge. These are essential dimensions of effective communication and deserve explicit, thoughtful teaching. However, their value lies in their purposeful application. Grammar is not simply a body of terminology and rules to be memorised: it is a resource through which writers make choices and readers develop understanding. Punctuation shapes meaning, emphasis, rhythm and voice; spelling supports clarity, fluency and communication. Children’s knowledge of these elements is most meaningfully developed through purposeful engagement with reading, writing and the study of language. We believe that teaching children about language should enrich their ability to use it, rather than become an end in itself. An integrated approach would give children a deeper understanding of how language works and greater confidence and agency as readers and writers.
We also support ending the publication of school-level Key Stage 2 results. An accountability system that places disproportionate emphasis on a narrow range of measurable outcomes risks distorting the curriculum and limiting the educational experiences available to children. In English, this can mean less time for reading for pleasure, encountering a rich and diverse range of literature, developing an individual writing voice, engaging in discussion and drama, and exploring the creative possibilities of language. These are not optional extras or enrichment activities to be fitted around the ‘real’ curriculum: they are fundamental to an ambitious and worthwhile English education.
Children should have opportunities to encounter texts that challenge, delight and move them; to discover unfamiliar worlds and perspectives; to develop their own interpretations; and to experience the pleasure and power of language. The quality of English education cannot be adequately represented by a small number of test results. We therefore welcome an approach to accountability that recognises the breadth of what schools provide and the complexity of children’s learning.
We welcome, too, the proposal to replace scaled scores with a competency framework. Children’s development in English is complex, cumulative and not always linear. A single score or a binary judgement of whether a child has met an expected standard cannot adequately capture the breadth of their knowledge, understanding and developing capabilities. More descriptive approaches, which identify what children can do and where their learning is developing, have the potential to provide much richer and more useful information for pupils, parents, teachers and secondary schools. In English, this might include recognising a child’s growing interpretative understanding, their ability to make connections between texts, their developing authorial voice, their confidence in articulating ideas and their increasing awareness of how language choices shape meaning.
Such a framework must, however, be approached with considerable care. While a descriptive approach has real potential, its development would require substantial consultation with the profession to ensure that it accurately reflects the complexity and interconnected nature of learning in English. It should avoid simply replacing one set of narrow measures with another, or creating a new set of reductive indicators that fragment learning into discrete competencies. Any framework should recognise the interconnected nature of the subject, celebrate children’s strengths and help identify meaningful next steps in learning. It should be developed with teachers and subject specialists, drawing on their professional knowledge and understanding of how children learn and develop as readers, writers, speakers and listeners.
We are more cautious, however, about the fifth recommendation: the introduction of random sampling of assessment across Years 3–6. We understand and fully support the intention to move away from a single high-stakes testing window and to develop a broader picture of learning across the primary curriculum. In particular, a focus on the full range of primary curriculum subjects is welcome. A broad and balanced curriculum is not an optional extra, but an entitlement for every child, and assessment approaches should reflect and reinforce this entitlement rather than inadvertently narrow the curriculum or privilege particular areas of learning.
This is particularly important when considering the experiences and needs of pupils facing any form of disadvantage. As the IPPR report makes clear, access to a rich and broad curriculum is an important matter of educational equity. We must ensure that assessment systems recognise the breadth of what children learn and know, and do not reinforce existing inequalities by giving disproportionate weight to a narrow range of outcomes or measures of attainment. There is therefore real value in exploring approaches that provide a more rounded understanding of children’s educational experiences and the opportunities available to them.
We note the further clarification that the proposed sampling approach is intended to support teachers, school leaders and the wider assessment system, rather than introduce another layer of unhelpful accountability. We welcome this emphasis and agree that it is important to explore how sampling might generate useful insights to inform teaching, leadership and national understanding of the curriculum. However, the intention to support the profession needs to be reflected clearly in the design, implementation and use of the approach.
Sampling may have considerable value as a means of gathering national and system-level evidence about the quality and breadth of educational provision. However, it is important to establish how the approach would generate meaningful and reliable information about curriculum breadth and equity, while ensuring that it does not create unintended consequences for schools, teachers or pupils.
There are a number of important questions that would need to be addressed. For example, how would schools be selected, how frequently would sampling take place, and what would determine which year groups and aspects of the curriculum were assessed? What would be the precise purposes for which the resulting data would be collected and used? Would findings inform national patterns and trends, identify areas where additional support or resources might be needed, or contribute in some way to judgements about individual schools? What safeguards would be in place to ensure that data gathered for system-wide understanding could not become another mechanism for school-level accountability?
We would also want to understand how the approach would support teachers and leaders in practical terms. How would the findings feed back into professional learning, curriculum development and improvements to provision? How would teachers and school leaders be involved in shaping the approach and interpreting its findings? Crucially, how would the system ensure that the process remained proportionate and did not generate additional workload or encourage schools to prepare pupils for the possibility of being assessed in any subject or year group at any time?
The unpredictable nature of sampling raises particular concerns about the potential for unintended assessment pressure. Even where the intention is to reduce the emphasis on testing, schools may feel obliged to prepare children for the possibility of being sampled, potentially creating a different form of accountability pressure and undermining the very curriculum breadth the proposal seeks to encourage. There are also important questions about the representativeness and reliability of the information gathered, particularly if it is to be used to make judgements about individual schools or determine where additional support is needed.
For English, there are particular challenges in assessing a subject whose elements are so closely interconnected and whose development takes place over time. A snapshot of one aspect of reading or writing in one particular year group cannot necessarily provide a representative picture of children’s capabilities or the quality of English teaching and learning across a school. We would therefore welcome further discussion about the purpose, design and implications of this proposal. In particular, we would distinguish between sampling as a means of understanding national patterns and trends, which may be valuable, and sampling as a basis for making judgements about individual schools, which requires much greater scrutiny and clear safeguards.
Ultimately, we believe that assessment should serve learning, rather than dictate the curriculum. Any new assessment approach must be judged not simply by the information it generates, but by whether it contributes positively to children’s learning, supports teachers’ professional judgement and enables schools to offer a rich, ambitious and inclusive curriculum.
Children deserve an English education that enables them to become confident and capable readers, thoughtful and creative writers, articulate speakers and attentive listeners. They deserve opportunities to encounter challenging and enriching literature, to explore the power and possibilities of language, to develop their imaginations and to find their own voices.
The English Association welcomes the opportunity to contribute to a more thoughtful and equitable approach to primary assessment. We hope that these proposals will help create an assessment culture that recognises not simply what can be measured, but what matters: the development of knowledgeable, curious, confident and creative young people who can use language with understanding, imagination and purpose.
The English Association thanks Kirstie Hewett (Chair of the EA’s Primary and Early Years Education Committee), Mia Sneyd (member of the EA’s Primary and Early Years Education Committee and Co-Editor of English 4-11) and Laura Spargo (member of the EA’s Primary and Early Years Education Committee) for their work on this response.






