What are the changes to statutory assessment and testing in the primary phase?
End of Key Stage 1 assessments will no longer be statutory from the academic year 2023 to 2024 onwards. This means that teacher assessment judgements in English reading, English writing, mathematics and science, tests in English reading and mathematics (the English grammar, punctuation and spelling test will also remain optional), and where relevant, using the pre-key stage standards or engagement model are now optional, with no legal requirement for schools or local authorities to report Key Stage 1 assessment data to the DfE, although there is still a requirement for schools to provide an annual progress report to parents or carers. There are no changes to other statutory primary phase assessment – all pupils will still complete the Phonics Screening Check at the end of Year 1 (6 years) and complete the full suite of teacher assessments and statutory tests and the end of Key Stage 2 (11 years).
Why have these changes been brought in?
The KS1 assessment requirements have been replaced by a baseline assessment, which now takes place within the first six weeks of a child’s Reception year (YR). However, while these are now in place, the first cohort of children who undertook this will reach the end of Key Stage 2 in 2028. Therefore, although the end of KS1 assessments are no longer statutory, the DfE considers that schools may wish to continue with previous arrangements in order to support the measurement of pupil achievement and help identify where pupils may need additional support as they transition to Key Stage 2. To achieve this, the DfE will continue to provide the assessment materials which means that a small number of schools will be required to support the trialling of these. Information for schools currently runs as far as the academic year 2025 to 2026, with optional tests for Key Stage 1 pupils still recommended.
When were these changes proposed?
Schools have known of the government’s intention to change the end of Key Stage 1 assessment and reporting requirements for some time, but the date was only confirmed in the summer of 2022, having been pushed back as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic.
What does this mean for schools?
On the one hand, this change to assessment processes means that schools will have far more freedom at the end of Key Stage 1. Teachers’ unions, such as the National Association of Head teachers (NAHT), have campaigned for many years to minimise the number of statutory assessments children have to undertake in the primary phase. There has long been concern among the profession over the impact of tests for such young pupils, with many schools considering that through the effective use of formative assessment, schools already know exactly where the children are with their learning and do not need expensively produced and time-consuming formal procedures to provide this information.
Further concerns over the assessment and testing regime have included worries over the narrow selection of content which not only excludes a wide range of curriculum subjects and pupil dispositions, but also reduces English and Maths content to only that which can be easily tested. The high level of accountability which is attached to statutory tests also drives schools’ provision with many feeling that there is a highly disproportionate focus on these few aspects of the curriculum, which significantly impacts the curriculum, affecting the wellbeing of children and school staff. There are also questions over the accessibility of the assessment and testing system, particularly for pupils with SEND or for whom EAL.
As the DfE have advised that they will continue to send assessment materials automatically to the vast majority of schools unless they formally opt out. Therefore, one concern is over the waste of money and resources with less than one in ten schools formally opting out of the tests. However, indications suggest that only about 60% of schools intend to use the materials. Such wastage may be particularly frustrating to schools, many of whom already face significant financial challenges (SATs: Primaries fail to opt out but won’t be testing (schoolsweek.co.uk)).
What does this mean for the learning and teaching of the English curriculum?
The changes to the statutory assessment arrangements mean that schools are able to draw on a wider and more meaningful range of assessment strategies such as small group and one to one discussions and observations of children’s learning. Assessment of children’s writing could be expanded to take in a wider range of authentic writing opportunities through which children have demonstrated their knowledge, understanding and skills. Children’s understanding and use of grammatical features and spelling can be considered in a contextualised way. Time which might previously have been spent preparing for moderation could instead enable teachers to design writing opportunities which include more elements of choice and agency. In reading, teachers can focus on ensuring children have gained greater fluency in Key Stage 1, without the added pressure of responding to reading comprehension under test conditions. Teachers will also be able to gather meaningful information on children’s strengths and next steps in relation to how they go about the process of making meaning from a range of texts.
Whilst the freedom that schools now have to choose their own assessment processes at the end of Key Stage 1 is likely to be a positive move, some schools may initially be uncertain of the best way forwards, and keen to avoid generating any unnecessary additional workload that devising a new approach may cause in the short-term. Schools may find it helpful to consider the impact of these changes on the full range of stakeholders such as parents and governors, as well as on their staff and pupils as they finalise their new approaches, ensuring that they are purposeful, efficient and valid. It will be important for all schools to consider the end of year assessment processes already in place for other years groups, and to identify whether these are suitable for adoption into Year 2, and will provide a full and detailed picture about each child’s learning which supports their progression effectively as they move into Key Stage 2.
Where can I find out more?
The National Education Union (NEU) provides a succinct summary of their views on the damages of extensive testing in the primary phase which includes some pupils’ perspectives. This can be found here: KS1 and KS2 SATs | National Education Union (neu.org.uk) KS1 and KS2 SATs | National Education Union (neu.org.uk)
The Independent Commission on Assessment in Primary Education (ICAPE)’s report, published in 2022, makes a number of recommendations, including that:
- assessment of pupils is clearly separated from the means to hold schools and teachers to account
- assessment of pupils provides a holistic picture of pupils’ achievements that reflects the whole curriculum, encompassing a wide range of understanding including creative thinking and collaboration
- assessment is designed to support inclusive education for all children.
The report is available at: NEU2762_ICAPE_final_report_A4_web_version.pdf
The Data Management Review Group’s report on workload (2016) may be worth revisiting to ensure that any approach is consistent with the principles and recommendations to reduce the workload burden on teachers. It is available at : https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a8014c5e5274a2e8ab4e12a/Eliminating-unnecessary-workload-associated-with-data-management.pdf.
By Dr Kirstie Hewett, FEA (Chair of the Primary and Early Years Education Committee; Senior Lecturer and School Improvement Specialist, University of Chichester) and Suzanne Hughes (PEYEC member; teacher with expertise in oracy and drama)






